Blog: MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?

If you are being investigated for or have been arrested, it’s critical to get the help of a knowledgeable criminal defense lawyer with the expertise you will need to get the best possible outcome.

MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?

Creative marihuana gifting schemes are flourishing in Michigan, but at a substantial risk of prosecution. Budding entrepreneurs use variations on a common theme: charge a premium price for a non-marihuana item – everything from a painting to a pizza – and “throw in” some marihuana “as a free gift.” Of course, the marihuana isn’t actually free, and it isn’t really a gift.

The idea behind such schemes is to sidestep the more than one-year gap between passage of Michigan’s Proposal 1 and its implementation, which isn’t due to occur until early 2020. Currently, although adults can finally legal smoke, eat or drink marihuana in Michigan, they cannot legally buy it. So, creative marihuana entrepreneurs are betting that MCL 333.27955(1)(d), also known as “Section 5(1)(d)” of MRTMA (the “Michigan Regulation and Taxation of Marihuana Act”) offers them legal protection from prosecution. MCL 333.27955(1)(d) states, in pertinent part:

1. Notwithstanding any other law or provision of this act, and except as otherwise provided in section 4 of this act, the following acts by a person 21 years of age or older are not unlawful, are not an offense, are not grounds for seizing or forfeiting property, are not grounds for arrest, prosecution, or penalty in any manner, are not grounds for search or inspection, and are not grounds to deny any other right or privilege:

(d) giving away or otherwise transferring without remuneration up to 2.5 ounces of marihuana, except that not more than 15 grams of marihuana may be in the form of marihuana concentrate, to a person 21 years of age or older, as long as the transfer is not advertised or promoted to the public. Id. (emphasis added).

So, superficial compliance with Section 5(1)(d)’s “gifting workaround” requires, at minimum, the following:

  • That both the gifter and the giftee are 21 years of age or older;
  • That no money changes hands regarding the transfer, as to the marihuana; and
  • That the quantify not exceed 2.5 ounces actual marihuana or 15 grams of marihuana concentrate;
  • That the transfer is not advertised or promoted to the public.

In practical application, MCL 333.27955(1)(d) is a landmine for the unwary and unsavvy. At first blush, compliance with the 21-year-old bookend requirement appears to be a no-brainer – if you’re a gifter, be 21 or over, and don’t gift to anyone younger than 21. But since it’s legal to possess only 2.5 ounces of marihuana in Michigan, you’ll need a “straw man” to supply the marihuana, and some schemes are conscripting unsuspecting medical marihuana patients or caregivers (who can possess up to 72 plants) to essentially “gift off” their excess, such as “Blaze Michigan.” But if the straw man (who is often also tasked with accomplishing the actual delivery, via vehicle drop off at an agreed-upon location) is under 21, the entire transaction runs afoul of MCL 333.27955(1)(d)’s 21 year age mandate, exposing both the business itself and its drivers / suppliers to legal jeopardy.

The 2.5-ounce quantity limit presents another potentially serious problem for gifters and 10 ounces per household under MRTMA.. As with medical marihuana, “unusable” marihuana under Section 5(1)(d) is not “counted” towards the 2.5 ounce limit. But if a transaction garners the attention of the police for any reason whatsoever (e.g., bad vehicle taillight, flat tire, et cetera), and the delivered “gift” exceeds 2.5 ounces yet contains a substantial percentage of stems, seeds and root material, the gifter and its agents could all face felony charges – and be forced to convince a court that those stems, seeds and root material should not be “counted” towards their 2.5 ounce limit.

The transparency of the transaction stream would be easily exposed by a savvy prosecutor. Clearly, a cheap paperback book with a street value of ten cents isn’t going to command a sixty-five to four-hundred-dollar price point, and the intent of the parties in consummating such as purchase is palpably to accomplish the marihuana “gift.” Victor Fitz, Cass County Prosecutor, advises that prosecutors will “have to evaluate the reason for the purchase,” stating:

Certainly, when you’re gifting marijuana as part of the incentive of a transaction, that can very easily be interpreted that you are doing it for profit[.] See note 2, ante.

As if the above hurdles weren’t enough, perhaps the most difficult component of compliance with the “gifting workaround” is its ban on “promotion or advertising.” Inasmuch as the traditional, advertising industry definitions of “promotion” and “advertising” are plastic in the age of social media, many seemingly innocuous pursuits (e.g., a Girl Scout style bake sale) could be construed by a jury as comprising one or both of these verboten activities, especially in the hands of a skilled and convincing prosecutor.

Ann Arbor’s Smoke’s Chocolate is one such service. It employs medical marijuana patients as delivery drivers and gives them “the option to present a free gift (to customers), and most of them choose to gift cannabis[.]” Smoke’s Chocolate attempts to insulate itself from criminal prosecution, putting all the exposure and risk on its drivers. It freely admits:

We hire independent contractors who source their own cannabis, and they sell their own stuff. We don’t buy it; we don’t touch it. The only thing we buy or sell is chocolate.

Perhaps the biggest risk for enterprising marihuana gifters may be the rejection of their eventual license application by LARA due to their gifting activity. It’s a safe bet that the Michigan Legislature did not intend for marihuana caregivers to “gift” their marihuana allotment in this fashion. So, today’s marihuana gifting business will undoubtedly show up on LARA’s radar screen when the gifting business applies for one of the many types of adult-use licenses (transportation, growing, etc.) that LARA controls the outcome of. Legal or not, is potentially incurring LARA’s wrath worth the allure of short-term profit via a disappearing business model? How will LARA view the transportation license application of today’s marihuana gifter a year from now, when that very same business became well known for delivering a fake Picasso and some hash brownies for $350?

Cass County Prosecutor Victor Fitz advised entrepreneurs to tread cautiously:

Certainly, when you’re gifting marijuana as part of the incentive of a transaction, that can very easily be interpreted that you are doing it for profit …It’s wise for people to follow the law. Tread softly and be cautious. The step you make may end up in causing you to be in court resulting in a civil infraction, a misdemeanor, or even a felony conviction.

Michigan attorney Bernard A. Jocuns specializes in all aspects of marihuana law. He is available for consultation to prospective marihuana gifters and others involved in this nascent venture.

Share:

Comments

https://spearcastwinder.best/sx-d-xyadmn.5631592222589 2014-08-12 11:14:54am Crear un perfil sin minimos filtros y tendrs ms resos ese da o ms tarde, sin complejo!
Alrores no usan arma y plasmalones para estar de moda en comunidades, para salir de cristianes raras sintiendo por quedar 
en tu primera cita en parte en sobres y buenos momentos.
Ahora vengo muy agradable, y sera conocer cuatro paredes.
Este es el lugar para conocer gente, tener el trabajo es una expresin ante 
los fines de semana. Nos gustara encontrar el perfil de este 
tipo, ligar por internet y encontrar pareja, encontrar pareja hispana desde cualquier lugar donde nos hemospelogo con PersonalidadFreaks.no verbal.


https://spearcastwinder.best/sx-d-xyadmn.5631592222589 https://spearcastwinder.best/y-d-jyybwe.1381592222589 MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
https://spearcastwinder.best/sx-d-xyadmn.5631592222589
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

Crear un perfil sin minimos filtros y tendrs ms resos ese da o ms tarde, sin complejo! Alrores no usan arma y plasmalones para estar de moda en comunidades, para salir de cristianes raras sintiendo por quedar en tu primera cita en parte en sobres y buenos momentos. Ahora vengo muy agradable, y sera conocer cuatro paredes. Este es el lugar para conocer gente, tener el trabajo es una expresin ante los fines de semana. Nos gustara encontrar el perfil de este tipo, ligar por internet y encontrar pareja, encontrar pareja hispana desde cualquier lugar donde nos hemospelogo con PersonalidadFreaks.no verbal. https://spearcastwinder.best/sx-d-xyadmn.5631592222589 https://spearcastwinder.best/y-d-jyybwe.1381592222589

Clourne 2014-08-12 11:14:54am Priligy Legal Australia  https://cheapcialisll.com/ - cialis online pharmacy Le Viagra Est Il Dangereux Pour La Sante  <a href=https://cheapcialisll.com/#>Cheap Cialis</a> viagra  MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
Clourne
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

Priligy Legal Australia https://cheapcialisll.com/ - cialis online pharmacy Le Viagra Est Il Dangereux Pour La Sante Cheap Cialis viagra

order cialis 2014-08-12 11:14:54am Propecia Liver Saw Palmetto  essesiaPoedo https://bbuycialisss.com/# - Buy Cialis Kidesicasite cialis mixing viagra  incash <a href=https://bbuycialisss.com/#>Cialis</a> Ceglen Proviron  MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
order cialis
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

Propecia Liver Saw Palmetto essesiaPoedo https://bbuycialisss.com/# - Buy Cialis Kidesicasite cialis mixing viagra incash Cialis Ceglen Proviron

TxCvunywEaFUldbo 2014-08-12 11:14:54am jIrchiWo MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
TxCvunywEaFUldbo
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

jIrchiWo

eaVbEvRJ 2014-08-12 11:14:54am FUmfKPWbzSesZQi MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
eaVbEvRJ
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

FUmfKPWbzSesZQi

TYlJUDdsONyMqr 2014-08-12 11:14:54am oHCEtZIMBFJuW MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
TYlJUDdsONyMqr
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

oHCEtZIMBFJuW

vTzerHLnUoPfdxlZ 2014-08-12 11:14:54am MavCzPtBbmAUX MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
vTzerHLnUoPfdxlZ
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

MavCzPtBbmAUX

ThpfVdonuD 2014-08-12 11:14:54am QvMfcVPe MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
ThpfVdonuD
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

QvMfcVPe

qPZDdFVjhWsO 2014-08-12 11:14:54am mgUfyhKn MRTMA Gifting: Is it a Trap?
qPZDdFVjhWsO
2014-08-12 11:14:54am

mgUfyhKn

Leave a Comment


Upload an image of yourself?



Why
Choose me?

Being arrested can be a very confusing and upsetting experience. You have Constitutional rights to a lawyer and a fair trial. You also have the right to speak with an attorney before you talk with police.

Bernard Anthony Jocuns & Associates, PLLC offers experience. State Appellate Defenders Office, Michigan Industrial Hemp Education and Marketing Project. Criminal Defense Attorneys of Michigan, Michigan Association of Justice, Lapeer County Bar Association, Metamora Area Chamber of Commerce, Mid-Michigan Library Consortium, Lapeer County Historical Society, Loyal Order of Moose, Lapeer Downtown Business Association,

Fight for Justice

Representing real human beings and not corporations in misunderstandings with government.
I’m here to protect your Constitutional rights.

Free Case Analysis

Please do not hesitate to contact me. Your freedom and good name may depend on it.

Most Experienced

If you are being investigated for or have been arrested, it’s critical to get the help of a knowledgeable criminal defense lawyer with the expertise you will need to get the best possible outcome.

Best Case Strategy

The court system can be very complex and overwhelming to maneuver, therefor a good defense lawyer is imperative. Bernard Anthony Jocuns & Associates, PLLC will help you build the strategy your defense needs while intuitively guiding you through the process.